How to Train Hiring Managers: A Step-by-Step Guide to Better Interviews

A shocking 99% of hiring managers admit they needed interview training after receiving it.

The US job market is booming with 7.7 million openings at 2024's end. The race to grab top talent has become intense. Companies take 44 days on average to hire someone. This long wait gives candidates enough time to accept other offers. The numbers paint a grim picture - more than half of candidates turn down job offers because of bad experiences. About 20% point directly to poor interviewers or weak interview processes.

Your organization needs proper hiring manager training to succeed. Many companies skip this crucial step and face serious risks. About 20% of interviewers ask illegal questions during interviews. This exposes companies to legal troubles, as workplace discrimination charges have a 95.8% success rate.

This piece will show you how to create effective training programs for your hiring managers that change your interview process. We'll cover everything you need to know about interview training - from building a well-laid-out approach to teaching core skills. These insights will help you improve candidate experiences and make smarter hiring choices.

Define the Role of Hiring Managers in Interviews

_{Image Source: Reed.com}

Hiring managers serve as talent gatekeepers for your organization and shape not just their teams but also the company's culture and direction. They must be fluent in assessing candidates, asking relevant questions, and identifying potential—skills that don't always come naturally.

Why interviewer training matters

Many companies underestimate interview training's effect. Let's take a closer look at this: a mere 32% of UK employers require interview training focused on cultural understanding and sensitivity. Only 23% train hiring managers on LGBTQIA+ awareness and just 14% on neurodiversity awareness.

Insufficient training creates serious problems. Untrained interviewers often rely on intuition rather than structured evaluation, which leads to inconsistent assessments and potential bias. HR managers admit bias affects their hiring decisions 48% of the time.

Training creates a level playing field where candidates get the same chance to showcase their abilities. On top of that, it helps interviewers understand legal boundaries—a vital point since 20% of interviewers have asked candidates illegal questions.

Common mistakes untrained managers make

Hiring managers without proper training make errors that compromise the interview process:

• Failing to define clear job requirements: Many interviewers begin without a clear picture of what they're looking for in candidates.
• Not creating interview scorecards: Without structured evaluation criteria, comparisons between candidates become subjective and unreliable.
• Talking too much: Untrained interviewers often spend more than 25% of the interview talking instead of listening.
• Asking closed-ended questions: This limits candidates' ability to show their experience and skills effectively.
• Skipping post-interview debriefs: Many teams fail to discuss impressions immediately after interviews, missing valuable insights.

Most untrained managers forget essential interview fundamentals: setting expectations for the interview process, asking concrete follow-up questions, and avoiding assumptions about candidates' capabilities.

How hiring manager interview training improves outcomes

Proper interview training delivers measurable improvements across multiple areas. Organizations investing in strong candidate experiences improve their quality of hires by 70%. Research shows 38% of candidates are more likely to accept job offers after positive interview experiences.

Interview training helps managers make faster, more confident decisions about candidates, which reduces time-to-hire—a critical metric in today's competitive talent market. This prevents delays that can cause top talent to accept offers elsewhere.

Training helps managers recognize and alleviate unconscious biases, leading to more diverse teams. Research proves these teams are 40% more likely to financially outperform their competitors.

Well-trained managers create a more rigorous, consistent, and fair process. Their understanding of structured interviews and effective answer evaluation naturally leads to more accurate decisions about candidates' potential contributions to your organization.

Build a Structured Interview Training Program

_{Image Source: SC Training}

Building an effective interview training program needs careful planning and structure. Research shows companies that invest in their hiring process see a 70% improvement in their recruited talent's quality. Here's how you can build a solid training framework for your hiring managers.

Set clear goals and expectations

Your interview training needs clear objectives. Start by identifying what hiring managers should learn and how you'll track success. Make a list of goals based on your organization's priorities. Then transform these into SMART goals (specific, measurable, achievable, realistic, and timely) to sharpen focus.

Think about setting objectives around:

• Expanding your interviewer pool
• Increasing equity in hiring decisions
• Improving candidate experience scores
• Reducing time-to-hire
• Creating consistent evaluation standards

Research shows that all but one of these hiring managers know if they'll hire someone within 90 seconds of an interview. So fair assessment practices become vital to overcome quick judgments.

Create a training curriculum

A well-laid-out curriculum will give a complete coverage of key interviewing skills. Your training program should cover these areas:

• Job descriptions and requirements analysis
• Overcoming unconscious bias
• Questioning techniques (behavioral and situational)
• Body language interpretation
• Active listening skills
• Legal considerations and compliance
• Evaluation methods and scorecards
• Note-taking to document accurately

The main focus should be teaching structured interview methodology that helps create a consistent process. Your curriculum should use different content delivery methods like role-playing, lectures, videos, group discussions, and practice exercises.

It also helps to get input from executives and department heads to make sure the training meets organizational needs. Tekion, to name just one example, runs weekly training on three core topics: candidate experience, interview logistics, and interviewer expectations.

Choose delivery methods: in-house vs external

The choice between in-house and external training providers needs careful review of several factors. In-house training offers better customization to your company's specific needs and culture. Your HR team can create content that directly fixes gaps in your hiring process.

External training providers bring specialized expertise and often have ready-to-use programs. When looking at outsourcing options, review the quality, time commitment, and cost for each choice.

Whatever delivery method you pick, your training program should have:

• Hands-on practice through mock interviews
• Opportunities to shadow experienced interviewers
• Practical tools and templates you can use right away
• Follow-up resources to reference later

Keep in mind that interviewer training isn't a one-time event. Organizations should see it as an ongoing process with refresher courses and continuous improvement. The most successful programs blend initial training with ongoing learning opportunities to create a lasting system for developing interviewer skills.

Teach Core Interviewing Skills

_{Image Source: Indeed}

Key interviewing skills make the difference between great and average hiring managers. Your training program's structure should focus on four key skills that affect hiring quality and the candidate's experience.

Using behavioral and situational questions

Behavioral questions help assess candidates based on their past experiences. Situational questions test how they handle hypothetical scenarios. You'll find behavioral questions starting with "Tell me about a time when..." while situational questions begin with "What would you do if..."

Top candidates answer behavioral questions using the STAR methodology:

• Situation: Brief context of the challenge faced
• Task: What needed to be accomplished
• Action: Specific steps taken
• Result: Positive outcomes achieved (plus optional learnings)

We trained hiring managers to prepare relevant questions that assess competencies linked to the position. A bank of pre-approved questions helps ensure consistency in all interviews.

Understanding and applying scorecards

Interview scorecards help standardize candidate evaluation. These well-laid-out tools ensure fair assessment based on clear criteria rather than gut feelings. They typically include:

1. Job-specific competencies and skills
2. Cultural fit indicators
3. Rating scales (typically 1-5)
4. Space for interviewer notes
5. Hire/don't hire recommendations

Hiring managers should focus on recording what candidates say in their notes. This helps them assess responses objectively against defined criteria, which reduces bias and leads to better decisions.

Reading and managing body language

Body language makes up about 55% of how candidates come across, making it vital to interpret these signals correctly. Hiring managers need to be careful when reading these cues.

Your interviewers should learn to spot positive signals like good eye contact, upright posture, and engaged expressions. Remember that nervousness is normal - don't read too much into fidgeting or similar behaviors.

Hiring managers must also watch their own body language. Good listening, proper eye contact, and showing interest through nodding and leaning forward creates a comfortable interview environment.

Avoiding illegal or biased questions

About 20% of interviewers have asked candidates illegal questions, which can lead to discrimination charges. Hiring managers need training to avoid questions about:

• Age, birthdate, or graduation dates
• Marital status or family planning
• Citizenship or national origin (versus work authorization)
• Religious affiliations or practices
• Disabilities or medical conditions

Questions should focus on job requirements instead. Rather than asking about childcare, ask if candidates can work the required schedule. Interviewers should prepare their questions in advance to ensure they stick to essential job functions.

Practice Through Real-World Scenarios

_{Image Source: Risely}

Theory alone won't cut it when training hiring managers—practical application turns concepts into real skills. Good interviewers build their abilities through hands-on practice in controlled settings before they meet actual candidates.

Mock interviews and role-playing

Mock interviews give hiring managers a safe space to practice their techniques without worrying about real hiring decisions. Managers learn critical elements during these sessions. They master tone of voice, body language, ways to make candidates comfortable, consistent follow-up questions, and note-taking techniques.

Role-playing exercises help assess how candidates might handle challenging workplace situations. The process starts with a brief scenario that mirrors their potential role. Participants get preparation time and a well-laid-out plan guides them through the exercise.

Real examples from actual interviews make the training more effective. "Interview training content can be pretty dry, especially if you're holding it over Zoom," notes Hannah Spellmeyer, Director of Global Talent Acquisition. "Make it interesting by using recordings of real interview moments, showing examples of interviews that went well and others that didn't go so well".

Shadowing experienced interviewers

Trainees learn best in actual interview environments rather than classrooms. Two main approaches work well:

• Regular shadowing: Trainees observe talented interviewers conducting interviews
• Reverse shadowing: Trainees conduct interviews while experienced interviewers observe and give feedback

This method speeds up learning and delivers measurable results in five key areas: faster time-to-hire, improved candidate acceptance rates, better quality of hire, reduced bias, and increased efficiency. Without doubt, shadowing involves prospective interviewers through tailored, interactive learning that classroom exercises can't match.

Virtual shadowing with recorded interviews offers more flexibility. Trainees can review at their own pace, jump to important moments, or watch at double speed. This approach also reduces pressure on candidates by having fewer interviewers present.

Using interview training tools and templates

Hiring managers need practical resources they can use right away:

• Interview frameworks and templates
• Question libraries for different roles
• Candidate scorecards
• Refresher materials or checklists
• Access to HR support when needed

AI-powered activities boost learning by simulating real-life hiring interactions. These tools let learners practice and refine their skills with up-to-the-minute feedback. These resources should live in your ATS or interview platform for easy access during actual interviews.

Evaluate and Improve Continuously

_{Image Source: Sprintzeal.com}

Training interviewers should be a continuous improvement cycle, not a one-time event. A good feedback loop will give your hiring manager training program the ability to adapt based on real-life results and changing needs.

Collect feedback from candidates and teams

Direct feedback from candidates gives crucial insights about your interview process. Only 22% of job seekers say they were asked about their candidate experience. Companies miss the chance to understand what works in their interview approach by not asking for feedback.

The best time to send post-interview surveys is after making hiring decisions. Candidates feel more comfortable giving honest feedback once they know their status. They won't try to impress interviewers anymore. These surveys should look at how engaged interviewers were, if questions were relevant, and overall professionalism.

The core team should gather detailed feedback from all interview panelists within 1-2 days. Fresh impressions help spot potential bias and evaluate candidates objectively.

Track key metrics like time-to-hire and candidate satisfaction

The right metrics show if your interviewer training works. Key areas to track include:

• Candidate experience ratings through Net Promoter Scores (NPS)
• Interview consistency scores between different interviewers
• Candidate drop-off rates that might show poor experiences
• Quality of hire assessments that measure new hire performance and retention

Better hires boost performance, reduce turnover, and help build positive company culture. Regular metric reviews point out where interviewers might need more training.

Offer refresher courses and coaching

Standards tend to slip with one-time training. Employee surveys can show where managers need extra support. Teams should review performance yearly at minimum, with extra sessions for those who need more guidance.

Regular meetings where interviewers discuss evaluation methods help keep scoring fair and reduce bias. These sessions target specific skill gaps found through metrics, like better candidate interactions or asking unbiased questions.

Your hiring manager training program gets better results when you keep evaluating and improving it. Interviewers become more skilled over time, which leads to stronger teams and better hires.

Conclusion

Organizations must invest in interviewer training to stay competitive in today's talent market. This piece shows how proper training helps hiring managers become skilled talent evaluators. They make better hiring decisions and create positive experiences for candidates.

Untrained interviewers often trust their gut feelings instead of using structured evaluations. This leads to inconsistent assessments and potential legal problems. A clear set of expectations and defined processes builds the foundation for successful interviewing.

Training hiring managers brings clear benefits. Companies with trained interviewers see a 70% improvement in hire quality. They also reduce their time-to-hire and get higher candidate acceptance rates. These managers build more diverse teams that perform better financially than their competitors.

Excellence comes from several key steps. Organizations need clear interviewer roles, structured training programs, and essential interviewing skills. They should offer real-life practice opportunities and set up continuous improvement cycles. Scorecards, behavioral questioning techniques, and bias mitigation strategies help evaluate all candidates fairly.

Your training approach needs regular refinement through candidate surveys, team input, and performance metrics. These help spot areas where managers need extra coaching. Making interview training an ongoing process creates lasting improvements in hiring outcomes.

The race for top talent gets tougher every year. Companies that train their hiring managers have an edge in securing the best candidates quickly. Start using these training strategies now. Track their effects and keep improving your approach. Your organization's future depends on the quality of talent you bring in. It all starts with well-trained hiring managers who conduct great interviews.

FAQs

Q1. What are the key components of effective hiring manager training?

Effective hiring manager training includes defining clear roles and expectations, teaching core interviewing skills like behavioral questioning and using scorecards, providing real-world practice through mock interviews and shadowing, and establishing a continuous improvement process with regular feedback and metric tracking.

Q2. How can organizations measure the success of their interviewer training programs?

Organizations can measure success by tracking key metrics such as time-to-hire, candidate satisfaction scores, quality of hire assessments, and interview consistency across different interviewers. Regular feedback from candidates and team members also provides valuable insights for improvement.

Q3. What are some common mistakes untrained hiring managers make during interviews?

Untrained hiring managers often fail to define clear job requirements, rely on intuition rather than structured evaluation, talk too much instead of listening, ask closed-ended questions, and skip post-interview debriefs. They may also inadvertently ask illegal questions or make biased judgments.

Q4. How can hiring managers improve their questioning techniques?

Hiring managers can improve their questioning techniques by learning to use behavioral and situational questions, preparing a bank of pre-approved questions relevant to the position, and practicing the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result) for evaluating candidate responses.

Q5. Why is ongoing training and evaluation important for hiring managers?

Ongoing training and evaluation are crucial because interviewing skills can deteriorate over time without practice. Regular refresher courses, coaching sessions, and calibration meetings help standardize scoring, reduce biases, and ensure hiring managers stay up-to-date with best practices and legal requirements in the ever-changing recruitment landscape.